It’s the biggest city in Japan. It’s quite a dense city, almost what Beijing is to China.


请教老师这个句子的句式结构和翻译。谢谢各位专家老师。

关于A is to B what C is to D. 我赞同刘老师的翻译。但关于这个句子的结构,我有不一样的怎么看。

我觉得what从句不是状语从句,what更不是连词。

我对这个句子的剖析为:

A 主语

is 系词

to B 状语

what C is to D 表语从句。其中what不只引导从句,并在从句中作表语,C为主语,is为系词,to D为从句的状语。

what为融合型关系代词,= that which。即融合型关系代词what引导的从句等于带有限制性定语从句的名词词组。

本句中的to B和to D分别是主句和从句的状语,而不是表语。由于主系表结构表示一个完整的逻辑意义,而A is to B和C is to D都不可以表示完整逻辑意义。比如:

Air is to man what water is to fish中,to man对Air并没表述用途,对air其表述用途的是what从句。“对于人”为状语。What water is to fish is the same thing as air is to man.